|
|
 |
 |
|
The B-26 Dunn safely flew back to France from a German bombing mission came to rest at the Ninth Air Force air field at Roi Ami. The props were damaged by the belly landing.
|
 |
 |
|
On Two Wings and a Prayer
|
 |
 |
|
By Al Zdon It was a pretty standard mission on that December 2, 1944. The B-26s in the 391st Bomb Group were to hit an oil storage depot in Sarrlautern,
Germany. Because of the weather, they were to use a "pathfinder" lead aircraft that would guide them to their target using radio beams. The plane was carrying 16-250 lb. fragmentation bombs, a full
load of 4,000 lbs. for the Marauder. Lt. Ed Dunn and his crew took off from their base in Roi Ami, in central France, at about 8 a.m. The clouds were thick up to about 7,000 feet, and it was
difficult plowing through them until the B-26s broke free. On top of the clouds, the group of 18 planes, six in a flight, formed up on the pathfinder, which had come from a different base. "By this
time we were all hoping that the war would be over pretty soon," Dunn said. "It seemed like the flak was getting heavier and the weather was getting lousier on every mission. Of course, I never said
anything to the crew about it. It didn't make much difference how you felt, you still were going to fly another mission." It was Dunn's 31st mission. There was a crew of six on the B-26: Pilot,
co-pilot, bombardier, turret gunner, waist gunner, and tail gunner. Dunn's regular turret gunner had been involved in a fracas and was in the stockade. Before the flight, a young turret gunner named
Ellerbe approached Dunn and asked if he could fly with them. He was anxious to get in his 65th and final mission. Dunn told him, "Welcome aboard." "It was the only time he flew with us. I'd never
seen him before." Dunn's B-26 was in the 4 slot, or the plane directly behind the lead aircraft and directly in the middle of the flight of six planes. It was a brand new plane, the first new plane
that Dunn had ever flown in combat. It was on its fourth mission, and it hadn't even been named yet. The pathfinder was directly in front of this lead group, and a flight was on either side. The
planes flews as tightly as they could, trying to minimize the target for the German gunners. Often the wingtips of the planes would be only three feet apart. As the planes approached the target,
maintaining the formation would get even tougher as the formation took evasive action. It took about seven seconds from the time a German .88 left the ground and exploded into the formation at 10,000
feet, the normal bombing altitude. The Americans tried to avoid the flak by erratic turning every 45 seconds or so, sometimes to the right, sometimes to the left. There was no pattern, and so the Germans
couldn't adjust for it. The problem was that even the planes in the formation didn't know which way the lead plane would go, they could only follow. For the planes on the wide edge of the turn, it
meant full throttle and hope you could hold on. On the inner edge of the turn, it meant cutting the throttle and hoping you didn't get crunched. With only a few feet between the wings, it was a little
nerve wracking. "You're just so busy flying, though, that you have total concentration. If you don't have total concentration, you won't be able to do it. Still, nobody likes to be shot at. My hand
would be shaking on the throttle." In fact, that type of flying had brought on an incident in Dunn's crew not too many days before. The turret gunner (who later got in a fight with an officer and was
jailed) had been known to have a drink now and then, and he showed up one night at Dunn's tent where the officers were playing cards. He said he wanted to see Dunn. The gunner was obviously drunk, and
he was in officer's country where he shouldn't have been. Dunn's co-pilot, Ed Armstrong, tried to handle the situation, but the man was adamant he wanted to see Dunn. When he got his chance to speak, he
slurred, "I want to tell Lt. Dunn that he's chickenshit. He flies too close and he scares me." The man was guided back to his barracks, but the next morning Dunn gathered the crew and gave everybody
a chance to change crews if they wanted. "They all said, 'No, no, no.' They wanted to stay. I told them we fly the airplane close to the others because that's the orders and it's the safest way to fly.
Flying like that was skillful, but it wasn't chickenshit." The crew on the mission to Germany that morning had been told that the target was completely clouded over, and that the bombing would be done
above the clouds using the pathfinder's electronic gear. When they got near the target, though, that was hardly the case. "The clouds broke away, and there was the Saar River. We were perfect targets
for the German gunners. You know the salvos are getting close when you can see the red fire in them. They'll bang you around a little bit. You can hear that rain of shell fragments against the airplane."
The Pathfinder needed a minute or more of straight and level flying at the end of the bomb run to find the target. Without the evasive action, the B-26s are in their most precarious position. The
Germans opened up. "The first salvo was really close. On the second salvo, a shell entered my rear bombay and exploded." The shock was incredible and the middle of the aircraft was blown to pieces.
Bits of shrapnel flew throughout the plane. The top turret gunner, Ellerbe, on his last mission, was blown away. Only parts of him were left in the aircraft. The waist gunner, Sims, next closest to
the explosion, was riddled with shrapnel. The main supporting beam of the fuselage was gone, and only the skin of the airplane was holding the tail section on. In the cockpit, Dunn was struck
in both the right elbow and his right ankle by shrapnel. "My body felt like it was hit by a sledgehammer. I was strapped into my seat, but the explosion spun me around in the seat. It was a big jolt."
The plane banked sharply to the left. Dunn tried to correct by pushing hard on the right rudder, but there was no response. He signaled to Armstrong to also lean on the rudder, but the plane continued
its steep left bank. Dunn was able to get the plane under control by using the power of the engines and the ailerons for the wings. After the slow, wide turn, Dunn's plane was now coming in over the
target again, but they had no idea if the bombs were ready to drop or even if they were still there. "It's not healthy to land an airplane with 16 fully-armed 250 lb. bombs." Armstrong left his seat
to survey the damage, and what he mainly found as he entered the mid-section of the plane was chaos. About 10 or 12 feet of the main beam of the plane was gone. The bombs, whose arming pins had been
pulled earlier, were hanging lopsided from the racks or strewn on the floor. The catwalk was gone. There were gaping holes all over the plane. The top gun turret was gone. The tail gunner, Wagner, was
trying to help Sims. There was no way to get to the bombs, or to even get past the first bombay. Dunn kept the plane on a heading out of Germany, but as the tail section swayed back and forth, it
seemed as though it would tear away from the plane at any moment. The cables to the rudder were severed as were the hydraulic lines for the landing gear and the propeller control. There was no radio.
"Both engines seemed to be running fine, bless their hearts." The bombardier crawled through his tunnel back to the cockpit. Dunn showed him his leg, and the bombardier stuffed bandages into the boot
to staunch the bleeding. After that, apparently overcome with the peril they were in, the bombardier sat down between Dunn and Armstrong and did nothing but whimper for the rest of the trip. Sending him
back to the nose of the plane, Dunn knew, with the chance they would have to bail out at any second, would be a death sentence. So he let him sit. "Besides, I was too busy to pay any attention to
him." There was some thought of abandoning the plane, and Dunn gave the crew that option. Armstrong carried a big sign back to the middle of the plane with "Bail Out?" written on it. The crew in the
back of the B-26 declined. It seemed the only way to get Sims to immediate medical attention was to fly back to the base. Meanwhile, The flight leader, Lt. Boylan, flew his plane back to find the
crippled B-26 and help guide them home. Boylan could see Dunn's plane was on the verge of flying into pieces. "All this time, the tail was swaying back and forth a foot or more. Boylan stayed at a
respectful distance." Dunn began a slow descent into the clouds, and the flight leader disappeared. They were on their own. Dunn had to fly on basic instruments, needle, ball, airspeed, compass, and
altimeter. He was able to maintain about 200 miles an hour, and he slowly came down, hoping to break through the clouds and hoping to find a place to land. When the altimeter said zero, they were still
in the clouds. The descent became even more slow and cautious. In the back of the plane, Wagner had tied a parachute on Sims in case they were given the order to abandon ship. When they finally
caught a glimpse of land, they found they were flying through a valley, with 800 foot hills rising up on either side of them. In the valley was a canal they thought looked familiar. If they were where
they thought they were, the plane was only about 100 miles from the base. Dunn thought they had enough fuel, but he couldn't be sure that the tanks hadn't been ruptured by a piece of flak. Dunn
brought the B-26 up to 1,000 feet and they flew in the general direction of the base, he hoped, and when they descended, they saw a landing strip. Dunn and Armstrong could see nothing out of the
windshield because of the rain, and so they leaned out of the side windows to observe the airfield. As they made their final approach, however, they found it was full of bomb craters. Dunn gave the
engines full power, and they pulled up just in time. Armstrong tried to plot their course on a map, and they followed a railroad track they guessed would take them to their base. By now, though, the
brakes on the props were slipping because there was no electrical power. The propellers were beginning to speed up and Dunn was again losing control of the plane. If the 13-foot props sped up too much,
they would hurtle themselves from the engines. "The engines were revving about 5,500 rpm. We were very close to losing the props." The situation was desperate, but suddenly in the gloom ahead, they
could see the distinctive church tower at Roy Ami. Quickly, Dunn found the field. The landing had to be perfect because the plane has no landing wheels, and the 250-lb. bombs were armed and loose in the
back of the plane. There would be no second chance. At fifty feet, Dunn cut the power. Unfortunately, as soon as the power was gone, so was his control of the aircraft. It veered suddenly to the
right, and began to zero in on one of the aircraft parked alongside the runway. Dunn saw with horror that it's the group colonel's plane. "Oh, lord, I've come this far. If I demolish the colonel's
plane, he'll kill me." Dunn dropped the right wing, adjusted the heading, and the plane crunched down on the runway and began its 4,000 foot slide down the concrete. Dunn and Armstrong pounded each
other on the back, shouting for joy. The rain helped to keep the airship from catching fire. "Of all the landings I ever made, that was the only good one." Dunn and Armstrong exited through the top
hatches. "I'm feeling no pain, just jubilation." It had been nearly two and one-half hours since their plane was hit. Medics came and removed Sims, still alive but just barely. "It was hell for us up
in the cockpit, but can you imagine what it was like for two and a half hours in the back with the tail swaying like that?" Sims survived the attack, but was a paraplegic. He died two years later.
Dunn has a letter from Sims mother thanking him for bringing her son home that day. At the aid station, Dunn was told he's going to be taken to the hospital at Amiens, about 30 miles away.
Still pumped with adrenaline, he turned down both morphine and a shot of whiskey. He even convinced the ambulance driver to drive out to the runway to see the plane, and the driver opened the back doors
for Dunn to see what was left of his brand-new B-26. "This flight was a miracle. Thank you, God, for our lives." On the way, with rush of excitement wearing off, the pain began to take its place.
Dunn told the driver he'd have the morphine now, but the driver didn't have any. The ambulance plowed over the rough roads for nearly two hours to get to the hospital.
The next weeks were a
series of train trips and surgeries as he was moved across France to Cherbourg. "Those guys were doing surgery over there in the most difficult circumstances and they did a fabulous job. The way they
could repair things was just amazing." On Christmas day, he was aboard a hospital ship en route to England. Christmas dinner was potato soup. Dunn recuperated in England, and later rejoined the 391st
for four more missions. "I wasn't the best pilot in the 391st, but I was the luckiest." For his effort, Dunn was awarded the Purple Heart and the Distinguished Service Cross, the second highest
decoration awarded by the Armed Forces.
|
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
|
|
|
Ed Dunn in his flying togs.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
Ed Dunn at his home in Apple Valley
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
Dunn while in training.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
One World War II history book said Dunn's aircraft was the most damaged B-26 ever safely landed during World War II.
|
|
|
|
About B-26s
|
|
|
"The B-26 might be likened to a high-strung thoroughbred horse which, if properly handled by men who know how,
will do anything for them but is more likely to kick the brains out of anyone who mistreats him or mishandles him." — Carlyle Holt, North American Newspaper Alliance
The B-26 came out
of its infancy with as bad a reputation as any airplane made by the United States for fighting during World War II. By war's end, however, it had earned another reputation, that of a top wartime aircraft
with one of the top safety records in the Air Corps. With the speed of a fighter and the bomb load capacity of a heavy bomber, it was one of the most versatile planes ever made. The Marauder was used
mainly for tactical bombing during the war, often just in front of the advancing American troops.
Statistics: The Martin B-26 Marauder. Wingspan: 71 feet. Length: 58 ft. 3
inches Top speed: 310 mph. Range: 1,150 miles (fully loaded) Powerplant: Two Pratt & Whitney 1,900 horsepower engines. Armament: 12 .50 caliber machine guns Bomb load: 4,000
lbs. Weight (empty): 24,000 lbs. Weight (normal takeoff): 37,000 lbs.
|
|
|
 |
 |
|
Dunn had it made when he was 16
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
Edward B. Dunn was born and raised in the eastern South Dakota town of Flandrau. Known as "Ebby" in his youth, he wasted little time in getting his life in order. By age 16, he had his own
job, his own apartment, his own car, and he was dating "the prettiest girl in town." On the side, he also attended high school and was the drummer for his school's award-winning band. Dunn was also a member of
the South Dakota National Guard, a unit he joined by lying about his age when he was 15 years old. He earned $1 for meetings and $15 for the two-week summer camp. By 1940, his enlistment was done. When the
war started, Dunn had already traveled over most of the West, and in 1942 he moved to Omaha to get a job with the Martin Aircraft company which was planning to open an assembly line there for the Martin B-26
Marauder. In the meantime, Dunn had also signed up and passed the test to get into pilot training. He was on a waiting list. And, no longer willing to live apart, he and Betty were married in June, 1942. Betty
moved with him back to Omaha, where he was earning sometimes as much as $100 a week at the aircraft factory. In October, he finally got his orders to report to San Antonio for pre-flight training. In November, he
found out he was going to be a father. Dunn received his wings and was commissioned a second lieutenant in August, 1943, and he was sent to B-26 Marauder transition training at Del Rio, Texas. On D-Day, June 6,
1944, Dunn and his new crew began a flight with a new B-26 across the northern route to England. Their payload was 3,000 lbs. of K-rations. After his combat injury in December of 1944, Dunn returned to France to
rejoin his group. He retrained on the A-26 and flew four more missions before the war ended. In civilian life, Dunn went into the insurance business in the early 1950s, and that led to various other business
ventures. Over the next several decades, Dunn and his partners became some of the largest land developers in the Twin Cities, including the Pentagon Office Park in Edina. Ed and Betty will celebrate their 63rd
wedding anniversary this year. They have seven children, 22 grand children and 14 great-grandchildren.
|
|
|
|
World War II Round Table talks over the B-26 part of the war
|
|
|
There was probably no military aircraft in World War II that had a worse reputation at the beginning of the war than the B-26. And there may have not been a plane that earned its fighting
spurs more by the end of the war than the B-26. This small, tactical bomber called the Marauder has not received the adulation and hosannas of such planes as the B-17 or B-25, but for a group of former B-26
crewmen at the World War II History Round Table in March, the Marauder was the best plane ever built. "It could carry a bomb load (4000 lbs.) that was the same as the B-17 (a heavy bomber) and it could fly at 310
miles an hour, the same as the Japanese Zero, the fastest fighter in the war," said former B-26 bombardier Ken Brown. "It seems impossible that these two features could be combined into one plane." Brown was the
featured historian at the Round Table at the Ft. Snelling History Center. He lives in San Francisco and has written a book titled, Marauder Man. Brown talked of both his personal military career and of the
research he has done on the B-26. He said he grew up as a farm boy in Northern Virginia, the ninth generation of Quakers. When the war started, he was faced with being an objector, like so many Quakers, or joining
up. He chose the Army Air Corps. After bombardier school, he wanted to get into B-26s for a variety of reasons including their reputation as a dangerous airplane. He also like the fact that the crews, usually six
men, were smaller than the big bombers, that they usually flew without oxygen, and that they attacked tactical targets such as bridges and supply lines. Brown attributes the B-26's bad reputation at the
beginning of the war to two facts. First, the Army needed the plane so badly that it had Martin develop the aircraft with no prototypes. The first B-26 that came off the assembly line was the first B-26 that
flew. "There was no opportunity for the inevitable bugs to be worked out. And there were some bugs." One of the major bugs was that the aircraft had a nasty habit of having what was called a "runaway
propeller" during takeoff. When this happened, the plane usually crashed and killed all on board. Brown said the problem was linked to the fact that the props adjusted electronically, and that a plane tended to
use all its electrical power getting the engines started. When the Army began starting the engines with generators on the runway, the runaway propeller problem went away. Another problem was that in the early
missions for the B-26, it was flown much like a fighter, a line of work it wasn't designed for. "The building of the plane was almost aborted by Harry S Truman, who was a senator then in charge of military
spending." Brown said only pilots who were in the top third of their class were assigned to B-26s because of the complexity of flying the plane and the higher landing speeds. By the end of the war, the B-26
had proved to be durable, effective tactical bomber. It's combat loss ratio was seven tenths of one percent, the lowest of any plane in the war. During the war the plane distinguished itself in many ways
including early success against the Japanese, the Battle of Midway, cutting supply lines in North Africa, and providing support for the troops landing at Utah Beach. The effectiveness of the Marauder was
evident, Brown said, at Utah Beach where the B-26s were able to come in at low level and bomb the beach and the water, taking out mines and also providing craters for the landing troops to take refuge in. At
Omaha Beach, where the heavy bombers were used, the support was not nearly as effective. The larger bombers, dropping from high altitude, lacked the precision of the Marauders. At the Battle of the Bulge, Brown
said the weather kept the planes grounded until Dec. 23 when a large mission was mounted to support Bastogne. In the morning flight, 16 B-26s were shot down by 60 German fighters, the worst loss on any day of the
war. "Within a week, though, we had almost complete destruction of the German supply lines." Brown eventually became a lead navigator for 27 missions, varying from six planes to 26 planes, guiding them to their
target where the bombardier would take over. The flight of six B-26s would key in on the lead plane, and as soon as the first bomb was released, all the planes would drop their loads. The result was an extremely
tight pattern of bombing, very efficient for bridges, rail lines and yards, and ammo dumps. Brown spoke of two missions he called his most memorable. On one, the B-26s experienced 45 minutes of intense flak, with
about 135 near misses around his plane. "No plane was shot down, and all 43 crewmen came back. It's a miracle beyond understanding." On another mission, the flight was battling 75-mile-an-hour head winds and the
planes began running out of gas as they landed. "One plane ran out just as it was landing, and the pilot had to land with a dead stick. Others ran out of gas as they tried to taxi in." Brown was followed on the
program by a group of veterans who flew on or serviced the marauders. Dick Brown, a pilot in the 394th Bomb Group, flew 66 missions during the war. He said he was in training when word of how dangerous the B-26
was filtered back to the U.S. "The Marauder was not built to fly at low level against the Germans, but that's how they used it in the early missions. On one mission, the 10 planes that flew over the target were all
shot down. "Back in the States, they didn't know what to do with the B-26s," Dick Brown said. Several of the panelists mentioned how the instructors for the B-26s fostered the bad reputation of the plane. "The
instructors didn't like the airplane too well and they'd transfer out as fast as they could. Once we got rid of the instructors, we didn't have any trouble with the B-26s." Dick Brown's 33rd mission was on D-Day.
"The weather was bad, and the ceiling was 500 feet. When I came out to the plane, I saw they had painted stripes on the wings. I wondered what the heck was going on. They told me that every fighter and bomber had
the stripes. The whole fleet had been told: 'If they don't have stripes, shoot 'em down.'" The pilots were told to drop their bombs before 6:30 a.m. when the troops were going to land. They dropped at 6:24. "I
kept thinking as I saw those landing craft coming in, if I get through this flak I'll be home having a steak dinner tonight, and you'll still be on this beach." Dick Brown said that the B-26s would often bomb
just in front of the American lines. "We would bomb so close that we'd release our bombs in friendly territory and the trajectory of the bombs would take them into enemy territory." After the war, as a Northwest
Airlines pilot, he had a chance to fly the Martin 202, the civilian version of the B-26. Joe Balach is a dentist from Duluth who flew 57 missions as a pilot in the 344th Bomb Group. He said he was working in a
steel mill in Duluth, shoveling dolomite into the 3000 degree furnaces, when he heard from his co-workers that they were seeking pilots in the Army. He traveled to Ft. Snelling on a day off and took the tests.
The only problem was that he had to wait nine months to get into cadet school. "It's a close-knit neighborhood in West Duluth, and after nine months I was known as the draft dodger." In training, his only major
problem was that he got airsick. "I was the only individual who for nine straight weeks bombed the Monsanto Plant with my lunch." Overseas, his commanding officer was a Col. Vance who took his work very
seriously. "If we couldn't find our target, he would turn off his communication with bomber command so they couldn't call us back. We'd fly around looking for another target. We called it the 'Tour de France with
Colonel Vance.'" Balach loved flying the B-26s "It's a tough bird, and if you have the right man flying it, it will do just about anything you want." A key to avoiding the flak, he said, was the technique of
flying in tight formations and then shifting course every 45 seconds or so. The German artillery would always be a move behind. "It was only the last minute and a half or so coming in on the target that you couldn't
do that. That's when it got really hot." Balach's memory of D-Day, taken from his diary, was that the group was personally given instructions by Air Marshall Mallory, the chief Allied air commander. The bombing
was done at 6:09 a.m., and the planes were ordered to stay under the ceiling which gave them very little clearance over the ridge at the beach. Balach also was in the flight that took out the bridge at Arnem, the
famed "Bridge Too Far" of Operation Market Garden. When it was determined the Allies couldn't hold the bridge, the B-26s were called in. "We came right down the river at 500 feet because we figured the Germans
couldn't depress their .88s enough. We pretty much made the bridge disappear and we had steak for supper that night." Earl Luikens was a crew chief for B-26s and he served all the way from North Africa to France
in the 320th Bomb Group. When he was assigned as a mechanic to the B-26s, his officer told him he could check out the plane and try to start it up if he could. "I was born and raised on a farm. If there's an
engine around, I'll start it." He came overseas on the Queen Mary during the cruise when it accidentally hit an escort ship, cutting it in half and killing its crew of 350 sailors. Luikens also talked about
the futility of the low level bombing that earned the B-26 such a bad reputation. "They came in so low that the bombs bounced up and took off the horizontal stabilizers." He crewed four airplanes in his long
service, and never once had a chance to go to a rest camp or do any R&R. After the war, Luikens worked at Northwest as a mechanic, and eventually worked his way up to becoming a commercial pilot. He worked for
42 years for the airline. In an earlier session, Luikens was talking about coming home from Europe on a ship that broke down at sea. "We were on the USS Johnnie Walker, and we didn't have any on board
either."
|
|